Right, getting sorted with my internet set up in my new house now. PC is in the 2nd bedroom/office'y type place, where the b'band is piped in directly to that room from outside (cable)

I also have a PC downstairs (it's a ghetto HTPC) and at some point I want to get a laptop - mainly so I can sit with it messing about on the net, msn, etc whilst watching TV in the living room downstairs, or use it when other peeps are round, so I don't have to be upstairs, and very occasionally I might want to use it in the garden on a particlary nice sunny day (hence the emphasis on the word "occasionally" )

The Cable modem I have connects to the PC directly via ethernet/cat5 cable upstairs, and what I DON'T want to do is run lengths of cat5 around the house, and even less so want to drill holes in walls/flooring/ceiling etc and have bits of conduit all over the place.

So the idea was to get a wireless router, connect the modem to it, then the main PC (upstairs) connect to the router via ethernet cable, and the ghetto HTPC and laptop connect to it wirelessly....

But then I got to thinking about these homeplug things. I reckon if I get a wired router (which I might be getting hold of a proper hardware firewall with built in 4 port ethernet switch/router) annd connected the PC directly to that (the firewall/switch), then took a cat5 patch cable to a homeplug upstairs, and fitted 2 downstairs - 1 for the HTPC, and the other with a 10ft cat5 cable for the laptop, which would be fine for sitting on both sofa's, and also enough length to reach out to the garden....

I only thought of it as I heard these are supposed to be very good now, and are supposed to be faster than most basic wireless networks, and also, other than the lappy going from sitting room to garden (less than 10ft travel really) I won't be "roaming" all over the place (even I am not enough of a nerd to use a lappy whilst sat on the toilet - well, not yet anyway) And since I am poor, I'll most likely be getting an old laptop anyway, so will probably be tied down to using it with mains power anyway!

What are people's thoughts on these homeplugs then? How much electricity do they sap? Ie, three homeplugs comparred to a single wireless router... How well do the *actually* work, and do they put any undue stress on the house mains wiring? (Bear in mind I would only be using the network connection for light internet use and possibly remote control over the upstairs PC via VNC or similar)

 

If you are getting a router then why not pay the extra, get a wireless one and not spend out on cable and homeplugs.

Flakit3 - HomePlug 85 Mbps Cable Router Broadband kit (2 plugs)
HomePlug 85 Mbps kit 2 homeplugs with wireless Router (Flarouter) and 2 homeplug 85Mbps (fla85)
Ideal for adapting NTL / Telewest / Cable and Wireless - Cable Broadband
Each: Ł81.60 ex VAT at 17.5%

http://www.pcworld.co.uk/martprd/sto...&category_oid= Ł50

I know what I would be buying

 

Adrian - true, there is the matter of cost... I might well be getting hold of a Cisco hardware firewall/ethernet switch thingy from a friend, so I guess all I need to plug into that would be a wireless access point and then both the HTPC and future lappy (when I actually find one I can afford!!!!) can connect to. But then I need to buy a WAP for the ethernet switch and a PCI wireless card for the HTPC and a PCMCIA or USB wireless dongle for the lappy..... So might end up costing similar anyway!

 

If you havent got the outlay for a router then you are half way there.

PCMCIA/USB wireless dongles are Ł20 from Pissy World, but dare say can be found cheaper on the web/ebay

WAP - Ł35
PCMCIA/USB/PCI card - PCMCIA Ł10, PCI Ł15, USB Ł10 - Ł20

Or this: http://www.ebuyer.com/UK/product/117886/rb/27591374094

Wireless router + USB Wireless for laptop/PC Ł37

I would presonally go for this though: http://www.ebuyer.com/product/48546/...rb/27591381690

All prices from ebuyer and inc VAT.

For me its a no brainer. Wireless all the way.

 

homeplugs are better for connectivity wireless networks drops out far too much for my likeing, plus there cheap aswell. why would you want a laptop in the garden for if its sunny you cant see the screen anyway lol.

 

Depends how well the wireless network is setup I guess.

I have had 1 drop out in the last 12 months on mine, and this was due to a power cut!

 

Adrian


PassionFord Post Whore!!





Joined: 22 May 2003
Posts: 4618
Location: Norwich, Norfolk, UK
User is: Offline
My car:

Posted: Mon May 14, 2007 8:06 pm Post subject:

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Depends how well the wireless network is setup I guess.

I have had 1 drop out in the last 12 months on mine, and this was due to a power cut!
_________________



wireless networks set themself up!!! all you do is have a choice if you wish too encrypt or not, you have been very lucky. when you send information wireless it only needs too lose a few packets througth walls or out of distance or even if sumones using a cordless phone, microwave etc

i use my wireless network for gaming a few packets means the diffrence of being in the game or not.