Zafiras catching fire
#41
I've sat through a few conference calls on this (I'm a service manager at a Vauxhall dealer) they're not recalling the cars.... only changing bits if customers make a call with concerns. They will put a stop to it I'm sure....but at the moment they haven't tested enough failed vehicles to be 100% that it's definitely the non oe resistors. Only tested 20 cars I think they said.
Its when people see a burnt out resistor and just lob a new one on without checking why it burnt out - normally knackered bearings in the fan motor. They then fit a cheap one on which is terrible.
Matt
Its when people see a burnt out resistor and just lob a new one on without checking why it burnt out - normally knackered bearings in the fan motor. They then fit a cheap one on which is terrible.
Matt
But it's pretty well documented on most Vectra forums about blocked drain holes in the scuttle
These block causing water to go down the pollen filter
Soak the fan motor which in time seize's the motor
Which causes issues with resistors blowing etc etc
So if you can't be Ar!ed to clear drain holes of leaves, which in turn causes other issues... Surely it's the owners fault?
Hardly Vauxhalls fault imo
If a owner can't be bothered to maintain their car it's tough sh!t...
It's not just Vauxhalls that suffer leaks through pollen filters...
#42
anyone else see the watchdog update on this yesterday, vauxhall should hold their heads in shame as they still wont admit theres a issue and worried owners are being fobbed off with 2 week waits at dealerships just to have the cars checked and more have gone up in flames since last weeks show too, way to go vauxhall
If vauxhall aren't recalling them all straight away, they're probably fairly confident that the problem is due to poor maintenance/cheap aftermarket parts rather than an actual design fault.
#43
Thread Starter
PassionFord Post Whore!!
Joined: May 2004
Posts: 5,730
Likes: 150
From: Surrey/Norfolk/Cambs
Not sure if Zafiras suffer the same as Vectras...
But it's pretty well documented on most Vectra forums about blocked drain holes in the scuttle
These block causing water to go down the pollen filter
Soak the fan motor which in time seize's the motor
Which causes issues with resistors blowing etc etc
So if you can't be Ar!ed to clear drain holes of leaves, which in turn causes other issues... Surely it's the owners fault?
Hardly Vauxhalls fault imo
If a owner can't be bothered to maintain their car it's tough sh!t...
It's not just Vauxhalls that suffer leaks through pollen filters...
But it's pretty well documented on most Vectra forums about blocked drain holes in the scuttle
These block causing water to go down the pollen filter
Soak the fan motor which in time seize's the motor
Which causes issues with resistors blowing etc etc
So if you can't be Ar!ed to clear drain holes of leaves, which in turn causes other issues... Surely it's the owners fault?
Hardly Vauxhalls fault imo
If a owner can't be bothered to maintain their car it's tough sh!t...
It's not just Vauxhalls that suffer leaks through pollen filters...
Seems to be more and more stuff, with people saying all sorts... Until Vauxhall find the exact cause, I'm sure they'll be loads more theories!!
#44
I'm not surprised more have gone up in flames, i bet there are loads of people that will be after 'compensation' from vauxhall after insurance jobbing their own cars.
If vauxhall aren't recalling them all straight away, they're probably fairly confident that the problem is due to poor maintenance/cheap aftermarket parts rather than an actual design fault.
If vauxhall aren't recalling them all straight away, they're probably fairly confident that the problem is due to poor maintenance/cheap aftermarket parts rather than an actual design fault.
#45
From what I have seen the cars that have caught fire are towards the older end of the scale and outside the manufacturers warranty. So even if they had been serviced at Vauxhall who is to say they have had the manufacturers recommended service or one of the masterfit type value service and mot's done that's basically a oil and filter change and a new air filter and when the likes of a.pollen filter and spark plugs are advised the customer has refused.
#46
Not sure if Zafiras suffer the same as Vectras...
But it's pretty well documented on most Vectra forums about blocked drain holes in the scuttle
These block causing water to go down the pollen filter
Soak the fan motor which in time seize's the motor
Which causes issues with resistors blowing etc etc
So if you can't be Ar!ed to clear drain holes of leaves, which in turn causes other issues... Surely it's the owners fault?
Hardly Vauxhalls fault imo
If a owner can't be bothered to maintain their car it's tough sh!t...
It's not just Vauxhalls that suffer leaks through pollen filters...
But it's pretty well documented on most Vectra forums about blocked drain holes in the scuttle
These block causing water to go down the pollen filter
Soak the fan motor which in time seize's the motor
Which causes issues with resistors blowing etc etc
So if you can't be Ar!ed to clear drain holes of leaves, which in turn causes other issues... Surely it's the owners fault?
Hardly Vauxhalls fault imo
If a owner can't be bothered to maintain their car it's tough sh!t...
It's not just Vauxhalls that suffer leaks through pollen filters...
#47
From what I have seen the cars that have caught fire are towards the older end of the scale and outside the manufacturers warranty. So even if they had been serviced at Vauxhall who is to say they have had the manufacturers recommended service or one of the masterfit type value service and mot's done that's basically a oil and filter change and a new air filter and when the likes of a.pollen filter and spark plugs are advised the customer has refused.
#48
Well the latest update on this is that vauxhall seem that confident its not the genuine resistors catching fire ect they only checking them and replacing if non genuine resistors are fitted or if another issue is found so i wonder if the chap mentioned above who has full vaux service history has ever had pollen filter changes?
#49
watched the watchdog thing and i have to say, it's very biased towards the owners and against vauxhall
even though they did say that it was down to poor maintenance and non genuine parts being fitted
even though they did say that it was down to poor maintenance and non genuine parts being fitted
#50
HA!
I thought it was a load of tosh, until a guy I work with came in and said his dads had just caught fire. It did NOT have an after market heater pack.
Really scary thing is that a couple of reports say that the doors dead locked when the loom melted trapping people in the car. Not very nice.
I thought it was a load of tosh, until a guy I work with came in and said his dads had just caught fire. It did NOT have an after market heater pack.
Really scary thing is that a couple of reports say that the doors dead locked when the loom melted trapping people in the car. Not very nice.
#51
so what the internet has taught us is the following:
leaves and twigs and stuff block drainage channels because no one cleans their car
pollen filters don't get changed because tight owners don't want to pay for the extra to get them changed
water rusts out the heater blower fan
this overheats the resistor
the location of this is close to the pollen filter
so when it gets hot it sets fire to the crap in the filter and therefore ends the life of yet another zafira
of course i could be wrong because i've listened to the internet
leaves and twigs and stuff block drainage channels because no one cleans their car
pollen filters don't get changed because tight owners don't want to pay for the extra to get them changed
water rusts out the heater blower fan
this overheats the resistor
the location of this is close to the pollen filter
so when it gets hot it sets fire to the crap in the filter and therefore ends the life of yet another zafira
of course i could be wrong because i've listened to the internet
#54
so they've bowed down to the few people who've not maintained their vehicles, who have skimped on servicing, declined the cost of changing filters to save money, used after market parts on their and then, when their cars catch fire, have blamed the manufacturer?
and the manufacturer is the scumbag?
and the manufacturer is the scumbag?
The following users liked this post:
STeve (06-11-2015)
#56
so they've bowed down to the few people who've not maintained their vehicles, who have skimped on servicing, declined the cost of changing filters to save money, used after market parts on their and then, when their cars catch fire, have blamed the manufacturer?
and the manufacturer is the scumbag?
and the manufacturer is the scumbag?
#58
so they've bowed down to the few people who've not maintained their vehicles, who have skimped on servicing, declined the cost of changing filters to save money, used after market parts on their and then, when their cars catch fire, have blamed the manufacturer?
and the manufacturer is the scumbag?
and the manufacturer is the scumbag?
My car had a full BMW service history from new and they never once changed the pollen filter!
So yes, if a pretty modern car catches fire I would tend to blame the manufacturer! There should be multiple safe guards in place to stop the heater motor from over heating for a start.
#60
Yes I would, I would say that say that Vauxhall have over looked some serious aspects of the design and as such it is not a coincidence that a number of cars are starting to fail at a similar time.
Cars catching fire due to electrical faults is totally not acceptable and Vauxhall should have included features in the design to disable things like a seized fan.
If you go even further back, why were people fitting aftermarket resistor packs in the first place? Because the original and probably massively overpriced Vauxhall part repeatedly failed prematurely. If they had designed that properly so they didn't fail people wouldn't have replaced it with a cheap part etcetc.
You can look at it from lots of angles, but for sure I can say that if my missus had a car that caught fire because of something as simple as a pollen filter being blocked, or because I hadn't cleaned out the drain tubes (seriously who thinks to do that?) I would be pretty fucking pissed off.
Cars catching fire due to electrical faults is totally not acceptable and Vauxhall should have included features in the design to disable things like a seized fan.
If you go even further back, why were people fitting aftermarket resistor packs in the first place? Because the original and probably massively overpriced Vauxhall part repeatedly failed prematurely. If they had designed that properly so they didn't fail people wouldn't have replaced it with a cheap part etcetc.
You can look at it from lots of angles, but for sure I can say that if my missus had a car that caught fire because of something as simple as a pollen filter being blocked, or because I hadn't cleaned out the drain tubes (seriously who thinks to do that?) I would be pretty fucking pissed off.
#61
but the point i'm making is that why have cars that range from 10 years old to 1 year old catching fire at the same time
they didn't change the design in those 9 years and yet everyone's caught fire in the past few weeks
which would suggest something else is amiss
they didn't change the design in those 9 years and yet everyone's caught fire in the past few weeks
which would suggest something else is amiss
#62
Yea, I get what your saying. Really I am saying something similar. To me that points to a design flaw, in that something is catastrophically failing before the end of the vehicles life. Thats why multiple cars of similar ages are being affected now.
Also, its the start of winter so people have just started using their fan heaters more.
Either way, if Vauxhall wrote "Please change your pollen filter every year or your car might suddenly catch fire, dead lock the doors and kill you" then perhaps they would have a leg to stand on.
As it is I really don't think they have anything to argue against. They have made a product which clearly has the potential to catch fire and hurt people, they had the opportunity at the time of design to install devices like a thermal cut out on the heater fan and they did not.
And besides, if it was a servicing issue with cheap arsed owners not servicing their cars properly, every Nissan Micra on the planet would have exploded years ago
Also, its the start of winter so people have just started using their fan heaters more.
Either way, if Vauxhall wrote "Please change your pollen filter every year or your car might suddenly catch fire, dead lock the doors and kill you" then perhaps they would have a leg to stand on.
As it is I really don't think they have anything to argue against. They have made a product which clearly has the potential to catch fire and hurt people, they had the opportunity at the time of design to install devices like a thermal cut out on the heater fan and they did not.
And besides, if it was a servicing issue with cheap arsed owners not servicing their cars properly, every Nissan Micra on the planet would have exploded years ago
Last edited by Rob_DOHC; 06-11-2015 at 01:47 PM.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
nicodinho
Ford Non RS / XR / ST parts for sale.
6
07-10-2015 12:56 PM