morto

Hello all if you could spend 10000 on a early Porsche would you buy a later model Boxter and if so which one or a 911..

Thanks
Andy

The Youth.

iTrader: (1)

an older 911 will in the long term hold a better value
the newer boxter would be a nicer drive
the boxter has to be an S


steve

morto

thanks mate what does the S have extra?

RC4

its boxSter chaps
i,d go for the latest,lowest milage s i could find

bigluke200

iTrader: (3)

Boxster all day long.. I've had a 986 box and a 996 c2 cab and the Boxster was a much better drive. A coupe 996 may be better but then I should imagine a 987 box is better again

Ginge !

Avoid 996 3.4 as terrible engines

996 C4 if funds allow,, turbo brakes and suspension just not the engine or spoiler but still very very pretty cars

plynchy

Boxster. Had 2. Both 986 models.

A 2.5 and a 3.2S. For 10k you'll get a good car, not sure exactly what as i'm not as clued up on the prices as I was but an early 2.7 987 isn't far off 3.2S 986 power and is a much nicer car in terms of looks and interior.

They all drive superb, and I mean REALLY well, different league to anything Ford i've been in. They sound superb as well. There'll be loads of hairdresser etc comments to follow i'm sure but drive one and make your own mind up. Buy on condition and history, they do lots of miles very easily.

Early 3.4 996's. as said above, avoid. If you want a 996 get a 3.6 but you'll struggle for 10k.

1.9 xr2 on 40's

depends on the use, daily-boxster

BRIGSPORT

iTrader: (2)

Be very careful, we rebuilt the engine on a 32k mile 996, 7k of a job. Do some research before buying one.

gjh

I'd take the best 911 you could find withing budget, after a lot of research.

plynchy

Why do you say that?

mulla

iTrader: (1)

ive noticed alot of these for sale have had engines replaced if you look through adds for them most say this

cfoster

I've only ever owned a 986 boxter S and thought it was ok, nice power and great handling, I just found it a little claustrophobic inside with the roof up. Mine had an engine rebuild before buying it 5k tag :S!!

Ginge !

The 3.4 does, ots the balance shaft seal and system, there is a mod for it but its 3k in parts to replace which is a lot even on a 10k motor as with labour your looking at around 4Kish

plynchy

The Boxster and 3.6 911's all suffer from the same 'design flaws', lot of units out there with no problems at all. Big gamble though.

BRIGSPORT

iTrader: (2)

The one we did got hot on the right hand bank i think and nipped up. Revised liners and casing, + new pistons etc. + machining work for extra oil and waterways = a big bill! Was done by a company called hartech.

Ginge !

Really, never heard that before, I have done a fair few 3.4 rebuild parts list, so much I had the part numbers in a excel document so I would copy and paste

Never had to do that for 3.6 and boxster I think window reg was a common faul but not done Porsche stuff for almost 5 years now I think

Oh I remember doing alternators and radiators for 996 turbo alot

plynchy

I know of several failed engines due to the balancer shaft bearings collapsing. I think Hartech have re-engineered a fix for it but it's not cheap!

CraigJ

Don't worry about the IMS. its not as common as its made out to be. I've been doing lots of research into the 987 Boxster and the 996 911 as i'm looking at buying in the new year.

From what i have been reading on the Porsche forums only around 5-10% have had experience with IMS failure. Its not a big cost though to have it swapped for an up-graded item. An american company do a kit for about $800.

Have an independent inspection done by a specialist prior to buying. this will highlight and potential problems.

I'm looking at either getting a 2000-2001ish 996 convertible or 2005-06 Boxster. I want to drive both first.

Insurance is cheap also. The Boxster for me and the wife is only £550 FC. thats £30 less than we are paying to insure the Wifes 05 Mini Cooper lol. The 911 is only £650 FC.

Cheack out Boxa.net and 911uk.com These were recommended to me on here and are great for info and seem friendly.

James @ M Developments.

iTrader: (2)

Im going to be looking for a 911 in the new year i hope

morto

well at least i can do the rebuild myself, so 987 from 05 plate onwards out of my price range!! and the 987 built in Finland... still look so sexy