View Poll Results: is fish a meat ?
Voters: 92. You may not vote on this poll
is fish a meat or not .. what you do think ???
Trending Topics
#10
2 camps for this with no definative answer. fish could be argued to be a type of meat as its the internals of a living thing.
it obviously depends on how you view it. Many religious groups have fasts where they say you can not eat 'meat' but you can eat fish, but others include fish in the sacrifice. Religious texts are also very old and the view's and meanings of things change over time.
If you pull out a currant dictionary the meaning of meat reads: 'The flesh of animals (esp. mammals) as food. (it says especially, which does not exclude other animals)
The meaning of fish reads: 'a vertebrate cold blooded animal with gills and fins living wholly in water. When i read those definitions a fish is an animal therefore fish is meat. I don't understand why vegetarians eat fish as they are living, breathing, they have a heart and a brain and muscles to function as land animals do, and recent studies show that it is most likely that fish do experience pain! Anyway it's obviously not a clear cut answer it all depends on your religion or just your personal belief.
If you pull out a currant dictionary the meaning of meat reads: 'The flesh of animals (esp. mammals) as food. (it says especially, which does not exclude other animals)
The meaning of fish reads: 'a vertebrate cold blooded animal with gills and fins living wholly in water. When i read those definitions a fish is an animal therefore fish is meat. I don't understand why vegetarians eat fish as they are living, breathing, they have a heart and a brain and muscles to function as land animals do, and recent studies show that it is most likely that fish do experience pain! Anyway it's obviously not a clear cut answer it all depends on your religion or just your personal belief.
Last edited by fuzzy; 26-04-2009 at 04:08 PM.
#12
It is not hard is it? It does not grow in the ground/on a tree etc, and it has organs, so it is an animal..... Meat comes from animals ... If you don't think it is meat, eat a fresh tuna steak, it is as thick as a pork chop, and is able to be eaten rare.. Very very tasty!
Vegetarians should be shot, as they are oddballs .
Just remember, dead animals taste good
Vegetarians should be shot, as they are oddballs .
Just remember, dead animals taste good
Last edited by RWD_cossie_wil; 26-04-2009 at 04:09 PM.
#13
my missus will wear leather but thats ok as its a byproduct of the animal she refuses to eat thats dead anyway but as the animals dead anyway you might as well eat it so it didnt die in vain.
i especially dont understand why she wont eat chicken but she doesnt have any issue with eating its unborn young? a very half hearted take on veggieism
i especially dont understand why she wont eat chicken but she doesnt have any issue with eating its unborn young? a very half hearted take on veggieism
#16
#20
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fish_as_food#Fish_as_meat
Wiki's answer..
What about PF's chefs, what do they say?
Wiki's answer..
What about PF's chefs, what do they say?
#22
I refer to it as fish rather than meat, but agreed on the veggies stance, if youre against killing things with feelings then why fish? What have the poor fuckers done to deserve it?
#24
#25
I've always disagreed with the popular concensus saying it's not meat, I am a veggie, but don't consider myself one as I eat fish, which I consider meat 100%, it comes from a living animal which in my book means it's meat.
tabetha
tabetha
#33
#35
#38