mk5 Golf Gti Vs Tdi overall economy?

[Lee Ivatt]

I have a mk4 gt tdi which the misses uses every day, and want newer car. so obvious choice is a mk5 gt tdi. but they are ugly as hell, so id want to put a gti bumper and trim on it as well as seats and wheels and suspension. Lets face it its gna cost at least £1k to put the wheels, bumpers, seats and lower the tdi. someone said to me over a year a diesel only works out £50 cheaper than a modern 2.0l petrol, taking into consideration all the variables! does anybody have the missing sums, this may sway me! realistic driving fiqures please not manurefacture fiqures as we all know they lie!! Mpg of GTi = 25-30 Mpg of tdi 1.9 and 2.0 = 45-50 Price of petrol =£1.15 Price of diesel =£ 1.30 Price of an 06 GTi 5 door =10k?????? Price of an 06 Tdi 5 door =8k??????? obviously i wont pay the full price as i can get them trade price I will be buying a car in the next few weeks, so please be honest/realistic I dont really want to spend any more than 7-8k. ive had expensive cars before and it depresses me to much! Id also like to point out i dont want a debate as to which it better/faster and all that, as i WONT be buying the car for speed. its more about styling and comfort and having a nice looking everyday car for the misses. thanks in advance

If you were logged in, you wouldn't be seeing this ad! Register your free account today, or log in if you already have an account.

[Lee Ivatt]

RIGHT

well ill round it to
tdi = 50 mpg (x2=100 miles)
gti=35 mpg (x2.86 =100 miles)
petrol = 1.17
diesel= 1.30
anyone please correct me if im wrong on following

4.54 litres per gallon

petrol = £5.32 per gallon
diesel = £5.90 per gallon


Gti = 100 miles will cost £15.21
Tdi = 100 miles will cost £11.80



so for 12kmiles a year

140 gt tdi
12000 miles / 51.4mpg / 4.54 litre's per gallon X £130.5 = £6,710

170 gt tdi
12000 miles / 47.9mpg / 4.54 litre's per gallon X £130.5 = £7,201

2.0 GTI
12000 miles / 35.3mpg / 4.54 litre's per gallon X £117.2 = £8,775


So even if i spent 2k changing a tdi to my spec. the year after i'll still potentialy save 2k per year over running a gti!?

[Matt Evans]

Dont forget the residual values of both cars need to be factored into the equation.

At the moment, RV's are all over the shop cos of the way fuel prices, road tax and the general economy, and it all boils down to how long your gonna keep it for?

[Lee Ivatt]

Originally Posted by Matt Evans

Dont forget the residual values of both cars need to be factored into the equation.

At the moment, RV's are all over the shop cos of the way fuel prices, road tax and the general economy, and it all boils down to how long your gonna keep it for?

well at least 3-4 years!
and tdi's seem to be 1-2k cheaper to buy!

[foreigneRS]

there is a good online calculator where you can work out fuel costs per mile etc

[vroomtshh]

Originally Posted by foreigneRS

there is a good online calculator where you can work out fuel costs per mile etc

Can you tell me more about that calculator?

[angel24]

Originally Posted by Lee Ivatt

RIGHT

well ill round it to
tdi = 50 mpg (x2=100 miles)
gti=35 mpg (x2.86 =100 miles)
petrol = 1.17
diesel= 1.30
anyone please correct me if im wrong on following

4.54 litres per gallon

petrol = £5.32 per gallon
diesel = £5.90 per gallon


Gti = 100 miles will cost £15.21
Tdi = 100 miles will cost £11.80



so for 12kmiles a year

140 gt tdi
12000 miles / 51.4mpg / 4.54 litre's per gallon X £130.5 = £6,710

170 gt tdi
12000 miles / 47.9mpg / 4.54 litre's per gallon X £130.5 = £7,201

2.0 GTI
12000 miles / 35.3mpg / 4.54 litre's per gallon X £117.2 = £8,775


So even if i spent 2k changing a tdi to my spec. the year after i'll still potentialy save 2k per year over running a gti!?

Have you checked the emissions too? As 06 plate cars are subject to the awful tax banding.

[angel24]

ok I had a look Lee, you may want to factor any insurance difference as well as the tax, which is as follows;

1.9s tdi 135g £66 for 6 months & £120 per year
2.0 gt tdi 149g same as above
2.0gti petrol 192g £115.50 for 6 months & £210 per year

All set to rise next year!

[smithy20vt]

Ideal you want a mk5 GT with the 170 bhp engine but with the decent kit and wheels etc

[Lee Ivatt]

Originally Posted by angel24

ok I had a look Lee, you may want to factor any insurance difference as well as the tax, which is as follows;

1.9s tdi 135g £66 for 6 months & £120 per year
2.0 gt tdi 149g same as above
2.0gti petrol 192g £115.50 for 6 months & £210 per year

All set to rise next year!

not really to fussed about tax. i pay nearly £200 /12mths each for the 3 cars anyway at the mo. so now with 2 cars it will be less.

also its a one off cost, which i dont worry too much about.

its the fuel cost which im concerned with as its a weekly cost!

insurance, im not even looking at the prices, as u know i get raped/pay £3200 a year at the mo, so now with 2 cars it will be much less.

Originally Posted by smithy20vt

Ideal you want a mk5 GT with the 170 bhp engine but with the decent kit and wheels etc

thats the plan!

i just dont see why VW dont sell the so called GT tdi with the Gti trim. surley they would sell loads of the bloody things, cos the tdi's at the mo are vile to look at from the front!!

[angel24]

Originally Posted by Lee Ivatt

not really to fussed about tax. i pay nearly £200 /12mths each for the 3 cars anyway at the mo. so now with 2 cars it will be less.

also its a one off cost, which i dont worry too much about.

its the fuel cost which im concerned with as its a weekly cost!

insurance, im not even looking at the prices, as u know i get raped/pay £3200 a year at the mo, so now with 2 cars it will be much less.

Just trying to help !

Fyi the petrol gti tax could go up to £400/£500 next year. I know I wouldn't pay it!

[Lee Ivatt]

Originally Posted by angel24

Just trying to help !

Fyi the petrol gti tax could go up to £400/£500 next year. I know I wouldn't pay it!

ud be best driving the S1 around, might be tax exepmt one day

[angel24]

It would almost be if they hadn't screwed the system!

[smithy20vt]

You don't really want Gti bits you need the R32 bits and OEM US Spec Parts

[foreigneRS]

Originally Posted by smithy20vt

Ideal you want a mk5 GT with the 170 bhp engine but with the decent kit and wheels etc

depending on the cost, it might be cheaper to get a 140 bhp engine and have it remapped up to 170

[smithy20vt]

Originally Posted by foreigneRS

depending on the cost, it might be cheaper to get a 140 bhp engine and have it remapped up to 170

Your 100% correct but it depends on if you want the additional spec of the 170.

[Diseasel]

What about a leon FR tdi..good spec and VAG engines?

[Lee Ivatt]

Originally Posted by smithy20vt

You don't really want Gti bits you need the R32 bits and OEM US Spec Parts

to be honnest mate the only bit on the r32 i like is the rear bumper! the rest sucks in commparison to the mk4 r32. dont even like the wheels!

Originally Posted by foreigneRS

depending on the cost, it might be cheaper to get a 140 bhp engine and have it remapped up to 170

i probably will do. as i'll be putting in leather gti seats anyway. so no point paying the 170 premium if its all coming out anyway!

anyway all the 170 is, is a chipped 140!

ive also heard a chipped 140 to 180bhp gives better economy than the standard 170

[foreigneRS]

Originally Posted by Lee Ivatt

anyway all the 170 is, is a chipped 140!

ive also heard a chipped 140 to 180bhp gives better economy than the standard 170

not really. the 170 bhp model can be remapped to give 30 bhp extra, as can the 140. if what you're saying was true, you could just remap the 140 to give +60 bhp