The Evo IV will bankrupt you in fuel alone and as a tight Northern git, you should be very worried about this .

I would personally go for the Evo, but that is because I have a Freelander as an everyday car. If I didn't have that and had to have one car only, I would also chose something like the BM, as it can do high mileage a lot more cheaply than the Evo. Alternatively, buy the Evo and a diesal snotter to do the daily grind in....