Old Apr 11, 2010 | 07:07 PM
  #23  
Rob_DOHC's Avatar
Rob_DOHC
PassionFord Post Whore!!
iTrader: (4)
 
Joined: Aug 2009
Posts: 4,790
Likes: 43
From: London
Default

Originally Posted by homer j
i work on harriers for a living in the RAF. the main reason that mag plugs as we call them were introduced is to monitor wear rates in the engine and associated components such as gearboxes or generators giving us an early indication of likely component failure. the use of mag plugs in car engines, especially road car engines, in my opinion is not massively beneficial. the simple reason being that the small amounts of metal floating around in the oil that Karlos mentioned won't really cause much damage as the tolerances are not close enough for it to make a difference, also how many tuners do you know of that have the same sophisticated equipment as the military or civil aviation companies that can measure the wear rates according to how much material the plugs pick up? in effect the plugs are not doing the job they were designed for, but instead are there to provide some piece of mind to users who don't necessarily understand the true function of what they have bought. if this is the case and people genuinely think that fitting one of these sump plugs is saving their engines then i suppose thats all that matters but i just thought that people might like to hear what mag plugs were designed for so that maybe people have a better understanding of there use. i won't be suprised if i get a bashing for this comment but at the end of the day that is my opinion based around a working knowledge of these pieces of equipment gleaned from nearly eight years working in the aerospace industry. the simple fact is it's down to each individual to make their own opinions, mine is that i wouldn't fit one as i see it as unnecessary.

regards

Tom
I agree with you to a point there Tom, it would be totally pointless to use a mag plug to prolong engine life in a military applications simply because the oil quantity compared with a motor vehicle is massive, and actually using them as they do (to measure engine wear) is much easier with large quantity's of oil.

Its all debatable really because the oil filter in a car is more than capable of filtering crap of that size.

I recently stripped my bmw's auto box to change filters and fluid, dropping the pan showed two large magnets covered in metal filings, there was NONE in the fluid (after careful filtering to see). More so the gearbox is stamped as "sealed for life", so to me the magnets were not fitted for inspections purposes but for removing ferrous particulates from the fluid (like they did), BMW being the tight German tossers they are really would not have fitted them had they not been of worth while benefit.

All in all i don't know if a sump plug magnet is worth it lol, but as Karlos says, it doesn't do any harm, and isn't expensive

Rob,

Last edited by Rob_DOHC; Apr 11, 2010 at 07:09 PM.
Reply