Thanks for the input guys, I still can't decide.

SCORTPOWER: I am based in Leyland, but do drop the missus off at Fulwood industrial so use the 31a Junc, close to the Red Scar park.

Each have pros and cons. The modding wouldn't stop just because I had the ST, but the 1.8 already has a stainless cat back, induction kit, springs, 17"s, and a couple of cosmetic mods. Things is I want something a little less boy racerish.

Seriously thanks guys, i need a good look round a real ST, then I will make choice, for those people wondering, no I have never actually stood next to an ST.
As for the new ST, just bought a house and cannot afford a ten grand motor.