I have here 4x Compomotive TH in 8x16 and ET25. Tyres are 215/40 ZR16 with still lot of miles remaining. Wheels are really as new. Just beeing painted, no scratch, no damage, new center caps, and stickers.
I would exchange them with OZ rally wheels (same as Monte wheels) in either magnesium or alloy, 8x17 without tyres.