Originally Posted by Turbocabbie

lets hope he's not innocent and deserves the punishment.

The problem with punishments such as this is the fact that if someone is wrongly convicted you have no way back and for this reason im not certain how I feel about it..

I think im all for this kind of punishment but only for repeat offenders.. for example if someone is a serial car thief, give them a few times to learn and then if they do not... off with the hands.