I've got a Young Sport and my 2.5 year old hates it.
Vision is way too restricted - yes it's very safe, but you have to have a 10 minute tantrum to pin the kid in there!

I guess it's partly my own falt because we have 2 differenmt seats for 2 different cars - as I didn't want to keep swapping the seats over.

I'm sure if she didn't know the much cheaper and more open seat existed, she'd be perfectly happy with the Recaro... That said, the other one reclines and the Recaro doesn't...