Black album for production and sound, but overal Puppets still wins. This album is STILL THE album by which ALL metal albums are judged - it is the benchmark for all metal abums....

I love the black album - it has heavy parts (Sad But True) fast parts (Struggle Within) and soft parts (Nothing Else Matters) but punch for punch, Puppets is still the best....

Tho my personal fave is And Justice For All