The Sludge

so which version do you prefer then?

the orginal of 1984

or the one of 2004

Zetec Andy

made into a poll, hope you dont mind

The Sludge

lol, cool mr manchester i thought i had 2 much to drink when i saw the post pmsl either that or i losing me memory

for me the original of 1984

richardeames

It will always be the original.

I think they should've dropped Dizzy Rascal really, he really spoils it.

Also they should have had both versions for sale in HMV/Virgin. Double the sales means for more aid money available which can only be a good thing.

RSBen

Defo original

The Sludge

rs_daz

Yeh the first one

Still sounds gd cranked up loud

Max

definatly the 1984 version.

The new one isn't that bad but they should NEVER have put a rap in it

EscortWRC

How about 'none of the above' ???

The Sludge

nope-not allowed

~Vix~

defo the original, they should have re-released that instead of producing that new load of cack!

James_RScos

i know its for charity but they should of wrote a new song because you can never replace the original of bandaid its a classic and shouldn't be spoiled with rap and shit like thar IMO

Stoned

who the f00k voted for the new one!!

own up!

The Sludge

lol-good question

xr_craig

iTrader: (2)

I like the old one but i wonder if in 20 years time if they do another then people will complain and say that it should've been left how it was in 2004.

Chipperx2

First one . Evan if you don't like the music, you have to support the cause, ( not my kinda music at all). I can see one right winger from across the pond doesn't seem to support helping poor people

Christian and Beccy

iTrader: (14)

I think they are both shite. OK, so the charity side of it is very much needed and I very much support that, but they might aswell put blank CD's in the cases, because surely no-one buys it because they like the song??

Also, was surprised to hear Bob Geldof quote on Radio One today, when asked if he thought Band Aid 20 would be Christmas Number One, "It is already Number One". When questioned, he repeated it. Sounds awfully 'rigged' to me.

Hofajoab

they're all crap and i can see them spending more money making the CD's and losing it all coz noone will buy it.. what they should do is no make a CD and put the money in the kitty!

I think we should have a poll, who actually donates any money, or busy the cd's?

i know i don't.. call me sad, but i'm one of these poor people

Lee @ Fusion

84 , without a doubt ,

2004 , fair attempt i spose but loose the crap rap !!!